Why recorded sales beat online estimates
Automated valuation tools work from public records and statistical models. They often miss renovations, lot quirks, views, condition and neighborhood boundaries. Recorded sales of similar nearby homes, called “comps,” are what appraisers and agents rely on.
Where to look up sales and property records
- Mecklenburg County Polaris: parcels, sale history and assessed values for Charlotte, Ballantyne and Steele Creek
- York County, SC: GIS and tax records for Fort Mill, Tega Cay, Rock Hill and Lake Wylie
- Lancaster County, SC: GIS and tax records for Indian Land
How to pick good comps
- Sold within the last 3–6 months (longer in slow or rural areas).
- Same neighborhood or a very similar one, ideally the same school assignment.
- Similar heated square footage, bedrooms, bathrooms, age and lot size.
- Adjust for big differences: finished basement, pool, garage, renovated kitchen, waterfront.
- Watch for non-market sales such as family transfers or foreclosures.
Ask for a CMA
A real estate agent can prepare a comparative market analysis (CMA) using MLS data, including pending sales and homes that did not sell, which public records do not show. For a lender-grade value you will need an appraisal.
Assessed value is not market value
County assessed values follow revaluation cycles and legal formulas, so they can trail the market by years. In South Carolina, increases in taxable value for a property that has not sold are capped at 15% per reassessment period under state law, which widens the gap.